The dismissive tone is unbelievable, especially from someone who touts how good those Alde chisels are or if you don't sharpen the same way and so on. This product may expose you to chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. Richter chisel blades are forged from this new Chrome Vanadium (Cr-V) steel, and hardened, cryogenically heat treated and tempered to a minimum hardness of 62 HRC. After initial hardening, cryogenic treatment cools the steel down using liquid nitrogen It took me a few months and now I am finally able to release my review about this chisel in comparison to the STANLEY Sweetheart 750 socket chisel. Happily they're all perfectly aligned. 59 hardness in the more mediocre line will lead to a more persistent wire edge. I "set them straight" about 2 1/2 years ago I think. Commenting has been disabled. The issue was that the flats were not indexed to the blades. Perhaps MJ's moan about his prompted those Czechs to improve their production process? At about 280 the Richter was still going strong and he was getting tired of the test so he quit. The issue with mediocre chisels is that sometimes the accommodation makes a chisel undesirable to use. While Narex managed to make the blades base corners very narrow, they also kept them away from being scary sharp. They aren't expensive either - about 1/3rd the price of Veritas PM-V11 and half or less the price of Lie-Nielsen equivalents. Sure there may be aspects that are unnecessary, but that doesnt effect the utility and at the price, why not? Personally I find FWW still the benchmark for detailed, meaningful and usually well-supported WW information. In the Richter line of chisels, Narex went even further and narrower the corners of the bevel edge to a minimum but strayed short of making edges that are too sharp to hold and handle. Narex Richter Cryo-Treated Bevel Edged Chisels - Set of 5, This set includes five of the most popular widths from the exceptional Richter line of bevel-edged bench chisels by Narex. Older chisel s had leather at the end of the handle, but the purpose there was to prevent splitting the handle end while pounding.
I do spend a lot of time sharpening before a project, like a half day going through all the chisels and plane irons. steel quality, durability, keenness of edge, general feel/ergonomics, etc.)? Lee Valley sells a Narex chisel whose edges are milled much closer to a true bevel edge. This guarantee will be void and compensation will not be made if products are damaged due to carelessness, neglect or inappropriate use. They are beveled chisels and got good marks on Amazon, but they are pretty cheap. View cart for details. Richter chisel blades are made from the highest quality Chrome Manganese (Cr-V) steel using traditional drop-forging methods. It's specified as chrome vanadium steel (there are tons of specs for chrome vanadium steel, at least as wide as 0.5% carbon to 1.5% carbon, so that doesn't tell us that much other than that it's probably fairly plain steel, which is good for chisels). The Richter Extra chisels are the finest chisels Narex has produced in its 100 year history. I have a set on th e way. One day I might sell my old Blue-handled Marples, although they've served me well for 25 years and still do.
Plus tips, advice, and special offers from Fine Woodworking.
I cant. Subsequent fine-grinding and polishing ensure a mirror-like surface with ultra-thin sides allowing reach into very tight spaces, making them the perfect chisel for cleaning out dovetails. There's something of "The Paul Sellers Show!" Narex makes an array of chisels, some of them have blades with walled bevel edges (see picture below), while the more advanced designs, such as the one that is sold by Lee Valley are milled to incorporate a bevel that culminates into a very narrow edge. All prices are in Canadian dollars. I haven't used the chisels, but I have forged chisels from water hardening files and made a lot of tools. Richter chisels are cryogenically treated during the manufacturing process. They are my second set because I sent the first set back. To this day, Narex is best known for making an extensive range of high quality, reasonably priced bench chisels. Frankly, I find much of his stuff far too hard&fast for my taste. Instead of 72,41 only 65.00 Only while stocks last, Compatible with Juuma T-tracks Instead of 10,67 only 8.50 Only while stocks last, Turn your work table, your workbench and your cabinets into mobile units! A year before the Narex box arrived I have learned that the company was intending to release a special line of high-quality bench chisels to celebrate their centennial anniversary. They were flat when I got them. I'm not sure what others are saying about the leather in the handles, I just got a set for the Richters, and there's no leather. The chisels are supplied coated with a light corrosion inhibiting oil with VCI protection for each individual chisel to ensure that they reach you in perfect condition. The burr did polish away and left a very sharp edge. edge retention properties, balanced with an ease of sharpening ability. Took about 15 to 20 minutes on each of the chisels to get them flat. We may receive a commission from sales referred by our links; however, we have carefully selected these products for their usefulness and quality. By incorporating the. to temperatures as low as 190 C (-310 F). The cryogenic heat treatment in liquid nitrogen extends the quench hardening down to about -196C, which converts the maximum amount of austenite to martensite, and increases both the hardness and dimensional stability. The feel, look, and finish of the chisel is impressive. I have been very pleased with the Narex quality and durability. I've had chisel edges fracture while chopping katalox and expected it to happen to the Richters. I have three Narex mortising chisels. Strangely, there seems to be little out there on this particular chisel given Wrights high praise. Now to see how well they hold an edge. I'll use whatever I get to try a similar set of 4 Narex Richter as all reviews I've read extoll their virtues.
The box measures 11-7/8" x 7-1/2" x 1-3/4". The Sweetheart 750 socket bevel edge chisels. The sturdy but old fashioned stapled together gray cardboard box held three sleek jet black capsules that contained the new Richter line of bench chisels. I have amassed a pretty nice tool shop and wanted upgraded chisels. It does feel a little bulky, but that's probably more about the mass of a 1.5" size. Richter chisel handles are made of domestically and responsibly harvested European Ash known for its strength, toughness and attractive grain. The bottom line (ha ha) is that the standard Narex items work very well indeed; come near ready for work with only minimal fettling of the working end; and are inexpensive partly because they don't spend enormous efforts on the cosmetics rather than on the functional aspects. This chisel is wicked sharp.
I bought a set of the oval handel (beech I think) Narex after I read a review hear but was not impressed. Decided to sharpen the 1 1/2 inch first. Together with the Two Cherries bench chisel, the Stanley Sweetheart 750 socket bevel edge chisels were perhaps the only chisels in the mid-range price. I just purchased a set of 7 Narex Richters. Blade Length = tip to ferrule edge. The steel seemed very hard and took a lot of work to flatten them but they don't seem to hold an edge as long as my old chisels. I have an eclectic collection of bench chisels, both old and new, superb and disappointing. Please read our Proposition 65 warning.For more information, see www.P65Warnings.ca.gov. Simple Woodworking Projects, Flattening a Plane Sole, Part 5 The Tools I Use to Measure Flatness, Where Art & Function Intersect: Meet Reid Schwartz, Paint Creatively on Your Walls With the Best Masking Tapes for Painting, Transform Your Garage Into a Cozy Workshop With the Best Garage Heaters, Draw Precise Reference Lines Every Time With the Best Marking Gauges, Level up Your Woodworking Skills With the Best Power Saws, Drive and Pull Out Nails Conveniently With the Best Claw Hammers, Keep Your Strikes Precise With the Best Dead Blow Hammers, Work With Ease and Comfort With the Best Cordless Angle Grinder, Make Your Furniture More Durable With the Best Threaded Inserts, The Best Wire Crimping Tools for Electricians and Homeowners, Connect Your Wires Safely With the Best Butt Connectors, 40 Years in the Making: A Timeline of Popular Woodworking. Exclusive special offers, deals and information about the latest products. I did look at Richters but came to the conclusion that, although they do have a better overall finish (polished handles, mainly) and a slightly different steel, they don't offer any meaningful advantage over Narex standard fare - which is already extremely good, especially for so little money. Here are a couple of quotes from a very recent Sellers blog that seem to illuminate the general issue: "THE FUTURE OF APPRENTICING To mark the hundredth anniversary of Narex, the company launched a new chisel series named after the companys founder, Vaclav Richter. I do not have experience with the Richter line, but I have a word about Narex fit & finish: I now have my second set of Narex mortising chisels. I recently purchased a set of Narex Richters for my son and I must say I am impressed, they compare very favorably with my Veritas vm-11s at a fraction of the cost. It holds an edge and sharpens well. In the Richter line of chisels, Narex went even further and narrower the corners of the bevel edge to a minimum but strayed short of making edges that are too sharp to hold and handle. The 1 inch, 3/4 inch, and 1/2 inch were all concave along the length of the backs. Neither the Stanley nor the Two Cherries have a true bevel edge. The bevel ground to an angle of 24 is more suitable for fine work and softwood. In my opinion, that's the most important issue of all. 2022 The Taunton Press, Inc. All rights reserved. I learned about the Richter from James Wrights thoroughgoing testing/review of a host of chisels (https://youtu.be/hYDLQ_gydhc), but I wanted to check out other impressions from the online woodworking community. are milled to incorporate a bevel that culminates into a very narrow edge. Great seller! They have a factory bevel grind angle of 25 degrees. It does have a touch of the PR-advert blurbs here and there but generally this can be easily spotted and winnowed from the extensive good crop of high quality guidance and advice. I just polished the edge with 4000,8000,16000. (Chisels sizes are actual inch measurements, not metric equivalents.).
Blade Forged from extremely high quality CR-V Steel.
Ultimately at less than 40 a chisel, I dont see how it could be a bad deal. That leather ring on the Richters (and on no other Narex chisel) seems to be part of the pretty-look marketing. Subscribe to the Workshop Heaven mailing list to receive updates on new arrivals, special offers and other discount information. Nice chisels in the end, especially for the price paid. The leather between the blade and handle is ludicrous. This Narex bench chisel is not sold in North America. Not to say that his websites don't contain anything of value - they have a lot of interesting and sometimes informative stuff. I own four of the Narex Richter (1/8, 1/4, 3/8, 1/2) and I have found the steel comparable to the Ashley Iles chisels. That's arrogant, solipsistic and something of a jarring cognitive dissonance, given that he portrays himself as a "woodworking guru" outputting his stuff largely via Youtube and other on-line channels, a lot of it paid-for "lessons" for which the free stuff appears to be the PR. I bought a set of 8 of the fat handled Narex chisels 3 years ago, to add a layer of better chisels above my 4 Marples and (very) old Craftsmans with the yellow plastic handles. One or two posters in this thread say they've had Narex chisels that have needed too much fettling - flattening of the back or re-configuration of the handles. The back of one of the wide chisels was so out of flat on the end I thought about sending it back or cutting the last 1/2" off. Has anyone been able to work extensively with the Narexs Richter chisel? Fine ground and polished with thin sides for reaching into tight spaces. Paul Sellers has been on my favourites list for a good while now . although I have to say his stuff is not really a favourite, more of an interesting perspective. In truth it was partly to drum up some tool-buying cash by selling some rather expensive items (such as Blue Spruce) the cash from which bought about 10X Narex items compared to what the equivalent Sprucers would cost. I was very excited about the new Narex Richter chisels and purchased a full set. The fit and finish is better than my Ashley Iles chisels as well IMO. The chisels are fitted with traditional pattern handles from Mr Richter's time, made from ash for lightness and strength, extremely smoothly finished and secured with a splitproof ground steel ferrule bearing the Richter logo and smartly trimmed with a thin leather bolster. It's often the case with those old WW curmudgeons who become set in their ways. Named after the founder of Narex Bystrice, Vaclav Richter, and launched to celebrate the centenery of his company, these superb bevel edged chisels bring Narex's signature blend of high quality and low price through clever engineering to the super premium end of the chisel market. Only the Richter chisels can be considered as true bevel edge chisels. And lastly, the factory promised to push the manufacturing envelope even further to ensure that the blades cross-section trapezoid geometry will be uniform and crisp, and thus allow it to sleekly slide into tight dovetails corners. :-). The Stanley bevel edges end abruptly into a substantial Land (an upright wall). I agree with John, putting a shock absorber between the mallet and the work makes no sense at all. In the case of a manufacturer defect in material, design or construction, a free replacement or repair will be provided. I use these mostly for dovetails, and relegate the rougher work to the older chisels; the old Craftsmans get the scraping and really rough stuff. You could pay far more for much less. When polishing the backs, where did you start in terms of grit - either waterstone, paper, or other. They have become well known for making high quality, reasonably priced tools, including chisels. He's very dismissive of so much merely because he doesn't have it or do it himself. When I first saw that particular line, I laughed. The Narex factory was founded in 1919 byVclav Richter, and while the factory has modernized over the past century, many of the manufacturing methods such as drop-forging are still in use. Start your 14-day FREE trial - and get building! The blade of chrome-vanadium steel is forged in traditional fashion, hardened, cyrogenically treated and tempered to obtain a minimum hardness of 62 HRC. Something went wrong. I had the standard Narex chisels and kept them even after buying all seven of the newer Richter chisels. Reading this thread I hurried off to the shed to make sure the handle flats and oval were properly aligned with the blades. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google, Editor's Letter: Technology and the future of woodworking.
This feature which I mentioned before is critical for enabling the chisel to excel in tight corners. I was impressed with the fit and finish. The ergonomic handles are sanded and then receive a friction shellac finish for maximum protection, comfort and control. I'd check there to see if he talks about these chisels. The new line of Richter Extra chisels will rival any premium chisel on the market today. However, there is blurb that claims the steel is significantly better as well; and is comparable to Veritas PM-V11 for both resilience and ease of sharpening. At an average price of $35 dollars, the Richter is placing itself in mid-price point, Narex makes an array of chisels, some of them have blades with walled bevel edges (see picture below), while the more advanced designs, such as the one that is sold by. Instead of 73,40 only 69.00 Only while stocks last, MHG chisels with side bevels ground down to the chisel face, Size Comparison of different Chisel Types, Free E-book by Friedrich Kollenrott: Sharpening chisel and plane blades. Made from a new type of steel alloyed with chromium for hardenability and vanadium for grain reduction and enhanced toughness, the steel is heat treated using a cryogenic process to maximise the formation of the desirable martensite crystalline microstructure in the finished steel. Narex Richter Cryo-Treated Bevel Edged Chisels, Richter Bevel Edged Chisels perspective view, Narex Premium 6-Piece Bench Chisel Set with Leather Tool Roll, Narex Premium 6-Piece Bench Chisel Set in Wooden Box, Inch Sizes are precise. :-). I am hoping the other chisels in the set have flatter backs. The blade is heat-treated via a Cryogenic hardening process which is considered by many as the most advanced hardening process out there. After 200 slices of oak the Stanley had developed a burr and would not cut the paper. Please enter your email address below to receive a password reset link.